demonstrations:dry_ice_comet
Dry Ice Comet
Materials: ★★★ Requires materials not commonly found in school laboratories
Difficulty: ★★☆ Can be done by science teachers
Safety: ★★☆ Some safety precautions required to perform safely
Categories: Astronomy and Space, Dry Ice
Alternative titles: Create a Comet with Dry Ice
Summary
Dry ice is combined with water, dirt, and other ingredients to make a model comet. The mixture forms an icy clump that produces jets of gas when exposed to light and heat, simulating how real comets behave near the sun.
Procedure
- Put on gloves and goggles for safety.
- Crush dry ice into small chunks and powder using a mallet, keeping at least half as powder.
- Line a large plastic bowl with a heavy plastic bag.
- Add 1 liter of water, about 2 cups of dirt, and small amounts of starch, corn syrup or soda, vinegar, and rubbing alcohol to the bowl.
- Stir ingredients together and mix in the crushed dry ice. Observe the white cloud that forms.
- Gather the bag sides and press the mixture into a clump. Add water as needed until it holds together.
- Remove the clump from the bag to show the “comet.” Measure its mass and record data.
- Observe gas jets escaping from the comet surface.
- Shine a flashlight (the sun) and blow warm air from a hairdryer (solar wind) onto the comet to simulate heating and tail formation.
- Re-measure the comet’s mass at 5-minute intervals as it melts, up to 30 minutes. Record results.
Links
Create a Comet With Dry Ice - NASA Video:
📄 Create a Comet With Dry Ice - NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory: https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/edu/resources/lesson-plan/create-a-comet-with-dry-ice/
Variations
- Compare comet stability with different ratios of water to dry ice.
- Use less ingredients to make a smaller comet.
- Use a balance scale to measure more precisely how the comet’s mass changes over time.
Safety Precautions
- Always wear goggles and thick gloves when handling dry ice.
- Keep students at a safe distance during crushing and mixing to avoid flying pieces of dry ice.
- Do not touch dry ice with bare skin—it causes frostbite on contact.
- Work in a ventilated area to prevent carbon dioxide buildup.
- Never store dry ice in a sealed container; pressure can cause explosions.
- Dispose of the comet by placing it in a sink to melt safely.
Questions to Consider
- How does dry ice sublimate differently from water ice as the comet warms?
- What do the dirt, starch, syrup, vinegar, and alcohol represent in a real comet?
- Why do comets develop tails when they get close to the sun?
- How does the comet’s mass change over time, and what does this simulate about real comets?