demonstrations:pieces_of_the_story
Pieces of the Story
Materials: ★☆☆ Easy to get from supermarket or hardware store
Difficulty: ★★☆ Can be done by science teachers
Safety: ★☆☆ Minimal safety procedures required
Categories: Lab Skills and Safety
Alternative titles: Science as a Puzzle
Summary
In this classroom activity, students each receive a random page from a cut-up book. They share the characters, ideas, and places from their page, and then the class works together to create a possible storyline. The demonstration illustrates how science often works with incomplete data to build larger explanations.
Procedure
- Cut a book roughly in half, separating pages.
- Randomly distribute individual pages among students.
- Ask each student to read their page and identify key characters, places, thoughts, or ideas.
- Record the shared details for the class to see.
- Once most students have contributed, challenge the class to piece together a possible storyline.
- Emphasize the analogy to scientific research, where only fragments of information are available and scientists must build models and explanations from them.
Links
📄 BOOK DEMO - Ashley Parker (Page 8): https://www.unco.edu/nhs/science/pdf/demos/2004_CSC.pdf
Variations
- Withhold some pages of the book as an analogy to missing data.
- Use different genres of books to compare how easy or difficult it is to reconstruct a story.
- Have small groups work on different books and then present their “scientific story reconstruction” to the class.
- Combine this demo with real scientific data sets, such as fossil records or astronomical observations, to reinforce the connection.
Safety Precautions
- No physical hazards are present.
Questions to Consider
- How is piecing together a story from scattered pages similar to how scientists work? (Scientists rarely have the full picture and must infer patterns from limited evidence.)
- What are the risks of drawing conclusions from incomplete information? (Possibility of misinterpretation or bias.)
- How does this activity illustrate the importance of collaboration in science? (Pooling individual observations creates a more complete understanding.)
- Can scientific “stories” change over time as new pages—or data—are discovered? (Yes, scientific knowledge evolves as new evidence fills in missing pieces.)