demonstrations:silo_of_salt
Silo of Salt
Materials: ★☆☆ Easy to get from supermarket or hardware store
Difficulty: ★☆☆ Can be easily done by most teenagers
Safety: ★☆☆ Minimal safety procedures required
Categories: Force, Pressure and Fluids
Alternative titles: Grain Pressure in a Mini Silo
Summary
This experiment demonstrates how pressure is distributed in granular materials like salt. When pressing down on salt inside a toilet paper roll, the force spreads through the grains and toward the sides of the roll, showing how pressure behaves in silos and why their walls must be strong.
Procedure
- Cover one end of an empty toilet paper roll with a piece of toilet paper and secure it tightly using a rubber band.
- Stand the toilet paper roll upright with the paper-covered end facing down.
- Fill about three-quarters of the roll with salt.
- Tap the roll gently on the table so that the salt settles evenly.
- Hold the roll upright and press a rod or handle slowly down into the salt.
- Observe whether the toilet paper at the bottom breaks or stays intact.
Links
Silo of salt - Experiment Archive:
📄 Silo of salt - Experiment Archive: https://www.experimentarchive.com/experiments/silo-of-salt/
Variations
- Replace salt with other granular materials such as sugar, flour, sand, or corn kernels.
- Try different amounts of salt (half-full vs. full) to see how it affects pressure on the bottom.
- Use a longer or wider roll, such as a paper towel tube, and compare results.
- Test the effect of using a pointed versus flat rod tip.
Safety Precautions
- Handle the rod carefully to avoid puncturing the toilet paper too forcefully.
- Work over a tray or protected surface to catch any spilled salt.
- Avoid pressing hard enough to cause the roll to collapse or tear suddenly.
Questions to Consider
- Why doesn’t the toilet paper break when you press on the salt? (The pressure spreads sideways through the grains, distributing the force over the entire bottom.)
- How does this experiment relate to real silos? (In tall silos, pressure increases along the walls rather than just at the bottom.)
- What happens when you use larger or heavier grains? (Heavier grains may increase downward force but still distribute pressure to the sides.)
- What is saturation pressure, and how can you find it? (It’s the point where increasing the amount of material no longer increases pressure at the bottom.)
- Why is understanding this principle important in farming or engineering? (It helps design strong silos and storage tanks that can safely hold bulk materials.)